Protect What Matters Most
Insurance That Protects Everything You’ve Worked For
Independent insurance experts helping local families and businesses find the right coverage, from the right carrier, at the best possible value.
We partner with top insurance companies
Personal & Business Insurance Solutions
Coverage for Every Stage of Life
From your first car and home to protecting a growing business, our team helps you compare options and choose coverage with confidence.
Auto Insurance
Reliable protection for your vehicle, passengers, and financial well-being.
Medicare Insurance
Clear, personal guidance to make Medicare choices easier to understand.
Business Insurance
Practical protection for your operations, property, employees, and future.
Why Choose Kotch Insurance?
Local Experience.
Personal Service.
Better Coverage.
Since 1988, we’ve helped families and businesses throughout Butler and surrounding communities protect what matters with honest advice and responsive service.
Independent Agency
We work for you, not a single insurance company.
Multiple Carriers
We compare trusted carriers to find the right fit.
Personalized Service
You’re never treated like just another policy number.
Competitive Rates
More options can mean stronger value and savings.
Claims Support
We’re here to help when you need us most.
Local & Trusted
Proudly serving our community for more than 35 years.
Our Simple Process
Three Steps to Better Insurance
1
Request a Quote
Tell us about your needs in just a few minutes.
2
Compare Options
We shop multiple carriers and compare the details.
3
Save With Confidence
Choose the right policy and move forward knowing you’re covered.
Ready to Protect What Matters Most?
Get a free, no-obligation quote and see how much you could save.
35+ Years of Experience
Serving our community since 1988.
8 States Licensed
PA, OH, WV, MD, NC, FL, GA, KY
Thousands of Clients
Families and businesses trust us every day.
Community Focused
We live and work right here in Butler.